POSTS ON
Books
Roy Thomson Part 6: The Conclusion
I’ve finished reading a biography of Roy Thomson’s journey. It was written in 1965 when Roy was around 71. Roy lived another eleven years. In 1976, he wrote an autobiography that focused on the building of his British empire. I plan to read it.
How Did Roy’s Early Years Affect His Trajectory?
Roy’s parents were working class; his father was a barber, and his mother was a maid at a hotel. Roy’s great aunt, Sarah Hislop, was not working class. She invested in mortgages, and she held the mortgage on the home Roy’s parents owned. Given the family’s limited means, paying off that mortgage was their highest priority. This dynamic contributed to Roy needing to work as early as legally permissible and dropping out of school at age 14 to work full-time. The contrast between Aunt Sarah and Roy’s parents made an impression on Roy. His parents were working to scrape together enough money to pay Aunt Sarah. Aunt Sarah’s loan generated income for her, regardless of whether she worked. Roy’s parents worked for money, and Aunt Sarah’s money worked for her. Roy wanted the latter. Like Aunt Sarah, he wanted to be wealthy, and he developed a “passionate devotion to money.”
Aunt Sarah noticed his respect for money and loaned 15-year-old Roy capital to invest in mortgages alongside her. Roy was instantly hooked—hooked on the notion that he could borrow money to purchase investments and buy things that would generate cash in the future.
Roy told coworkers he’d be a millionaire by age 30. He didn’t achieve that goal, but becoming wealthy became the driving force in his life.
What Strategy Did Roy Employ to Achieve Success?
Roy learned that selling physical products and scaling that business model is complex. To sell more products, you need more inventory; to buy more inventory, you need capital to purchase it and, sometimes, expand your capability to store it.
Roy created a radio station as a way to sell more radios but quickly learned it was much easier to increase revenue in a radio station than in a company selling radios. The more listeners tuned in, the more people the ads reached and the more Roy could charge for advertising. He realized that radio broadcasting as a business model had leverage because his costs remained the same as listeners and ad revenue increased. The cost of marginal replication was low or zero, and revenue increases could happen rapidly. This was true for television broadcasting and newspapers too, which he expanded into. Media became the backbone of Roy’s strategy. Whether his customers were reading newspapers, listening to radio, or watching TV, Roy could sell their attention to advertisers for a profit.
Starting a radio station, television station, or newspaper from scratch is hard and takes time. Roy started off doing this but realized he preferred to improve existing properties. An underperforming property could be acquired for a low multiple (i.e., low price), especially if it was in a rural town and had been family-owned for generations. Once it was improved and benefiting from the economies of scale by being part of his empire, it could rapidly produce more cash. Buying media properties, improving operations, and generating cash became vital to Roy’s strategy.
Roy said, “My fortune is as large as my credit rating . . . and my credit rating is limitless.” This pretty much sums up the next part of Roy’s strategy. He believed in using debt, a form of capital leverage, to obtain the capital needed to acquire media properties. He understood two things about debt:
- Rate of return – Roy used borrowed money when the potential rate of return exceeded his interest rate. For example, when he could borrow money at 5% and buy an asset that in a year would generate a cash return of at least 10% of the purchase price, buying that asset with debt made sense.
- Ownership – Roy was focused on the companies he acquired generating cash years into the future. He didn’t give up ownership in his companies when he used debt, which meant he owned those future cash flow streams (after the debt was paid off). If he’d raised capital by selling equity (i.e., ownership), other investors would own part of those future cash flow streams in perpetuity.
Another thing that stood out to me was how Roy used two forms of leverage. He combined a highly scalable media business model (low to no cost of marginal replication) with capital leverage (debt). The combination of the two, along with luck and a focus on cash flow, turbocharged his ability to build his empire and wealth.
What about Roy’s Execution Made Him Successful?
Roy eventually learned to stay out of the details and focus on strategy and acquisitions. Like many entrepreneurs, he learned this the hard way. After years of being in the weeds, he hired Jack Kent Cooke, who freed him up. He learned his company could move faster with him out of the details. From that point on, he ran a decentralized company with nonfinancial decision-making at each media property that aligned with the community being served. Henry Singleton at Teledyne and Warren Buffett at Berkshire Hathaway used similar approaches.
Roy also put a ton of hours into his work. He was known to work sixteen- and seventeen-hour days and sometimes wouldn’t see his family until the weekend. He got more done than the average person. Working that much had a downside, though. When his wife passed away, he regretted not spending more time with her.
Roy’s story was inspiring. He failed for many years, first as a farmer, then selling automotive parts, and then as an electronics retailer, before realizing the power of media. But when he figured it out, he excelled. He built an empire that still stands today.
Roy Thomson Part 5: A £100 Million Empire
Access to capital was key to Roy Thomson’s acquisition strategy and success, according to the biography I'm reading. When possible, he avoided selling equity (ownership) in his company to raise capital. He wanted all the profits he knew he’d eventually generate to be his, not other shareholders’. He also despised the idea of having to deal with a board of directors, seeing the conflicting opinions of directors as a waste of his time. Roy believed that if he could borrow at 5% and get a return of 10% or more on the borrowed capital, it was sensible to raise capital through debt instead of selling equity.
In 1955, Roy publicly declared his intent to bid for the charter to launch an independent Scottish television station. No one in Scotland understood the opportunity like Roy did, and the elites declined to invest. He even asked colleagues at All-Canada Radio to partner with him, but they too declined. These people didn’t know that Roy had obsessed over this station and done extensive research, sending his lieutenant to tour American and Canadian stations and ask questions about budgets. Roy analyzed spending per capita in Scotland compared to England to determine what ad rates he could charge. His work paid off, and in May 1956, regulators gave Roy a charter to establish Scottish Television Limited (STV), which he was chairman of.
To finance the deal, Roy tried to borrow £400,000, but the Scottish bank gave him only £240,000, which surprised him. Roy assembled an investor group and valued the company at £400,000, equal to the required start-up capital. Roy was £160,000 short of his goal and decided to raise it primarily by issuing £120,000 in bonds, but also by selling 40,000 shares of equity for £40,000 to an investor group. Roy was one of the investors in that group; he bought £32,000 worth, or 80%. Instead of spending £400,000 of his own funds to own 100%, Roy spent £32,0000 to own 80%. He’d sold as little company equity as possible and managed to keep control and as much of the eventual profits as possible.
STV was a big hit. In its first month, STV made a £10,000 profit. Quickly, it was on track to do £1,000,000 in profit in the first year. Nobody except Roy had expected STV to turn a profit. Within two years, those 40,000 shares in STV that were initially worth £400,000 exploded in value to millions—so much so that Roy used them as part of a transaction to purchase an entire chain of British newspapers.
In 1958, Kemsley Press, a prestigious company that owned eighteen British newspapers, asked Roy if he was still interested in acquiring them. The deal was done in a complicated transaction that took sixteen intense days to negotiate. It had three parts:
- Kemsley Press acquired STV from Roy for £5.5 million: £1 million in cash, £500,000 in bonds, and £4 million in newly issued Kemsley shares
- Roy then bought Lord Kemsley’s controlling stake in Kemsley Press for £5 million: £1 million cash from the prior transaction, a £1 million promissory note with a ten-year term, and £3 million in cash that Roy borrowed from the bank.
- Roy made a tender offer (i.e., offered to buy at a set price) for Kemsley shares owned by other minority shareholders, too.
In roughly seven years, Roy had gone from electoral defeat in Canada to becoming a press baron in the United Kingdom. With the Kemsley deal, he’d reached his goal of owning fifty-two newspapers. At age 40, Roy was broke and heavily indebted. By age 65, he had empires in two countries on different continents. Roy continued to build his empire and expanded to have newspapers in Africa, Australia, and other places.
Roy also achieved his other goal and was given the title “baron” in 1964, becoming Lord Thomson of Fleet Street. Roy had reached the upper echelon of elite global circles, and he did it his way, on his terms. By 1964, his hard work had created an empire valued at roughly £100 million. His family is still one of the wealthiest, if not the wealthiest, families in Canada.
Roy passed away in 1976 at the age of 82, but his family continues to run his empire. In 2008, Roy’s Thomson Corporation acquired Reuters Group plc to form what is now known as Thomson Reuters, a multinational information company with a market capitalization (i.e., valuation) of roughly $74 billion as of this writing.
Roy Thomson was a dynamic entrepreneur who built a massive newspaper and media empire through savvy dealmaking and a dogged work ethic.
Roy Thomson Part 4: Great Britain Here I Come
After his separation from Jack Kent Cooke, Roy Thomson kept moving forward. He continued to try to pierce the upper echelons of Canadian society by joining the board of the prestigious Albany Club in Toronto. He bought three more Canadian newspapers and issued $3 million in bonds to finance these and other purchases. He hired a right-hand man with an encyclopedic knowledge of Canadian newspaper statistics who improved his sourcing of newspapers to purchase. He was well on his way to achieving his publicly stated goal of owning 52 papers, one for each week of the year. Everything was trending upward until his wife, Edna, was diagnosed with cancer in 1951 and passed away in 1952. After she passed, Roy regretted working so much and not spending more time at home with her.
As a widower, Roy did what he knew best: he dove into his work and his presidency at Canadian Press, a trade association. As president, Roy preached to publishers that broadcasting wouldn’t kill newspapers, technology was expensive up front but cheap in the long run, and television shouldn’t be feared because television and radio stations could buy news from Canadian Press. Roy also bought seven more Canadian newspapers during his tenure as president and a Florida newspaper while vacationing in the state.
Continuing to try to grow his networks and influence in the upper echelons, Roy ran for Parliament of Canada as a progressive conservative candidate. He was defeated. Undeterred, he refocused on his business and decided to expand into Great Britain. In 1953, he began printing a weekly magazine for Canadians living in Britain. Then The Scotsman, a prestigious newspaper in Scotland, asked Roy if he was still interested in buying it. The newspaper had been mismanaged after the World War II boom and was losing money. To transfer ownership to the next generation, its owner would face a death tax it couldn’t afford. Roy bought The Scotsman and two sister papers. The deal stipulated that he become a resident publisher. At 59, he moved to Edinburgh, Scotland, to build another empire.
Roy transferred management of his North American and Caribbean businesses to his son Kenneth and executives. He focused intensely on turning around The Scotsman, but things didn’t go as planned. Roy cycled through a few editors, and circulation dropped. Edinburgh’s high society, which initially wanted to get to know Roy, shunned him because of his blunt demeanor and changes he made to their local newspapers. Unsure how to turn things around, Roy offered Jack 25% ownership for free if he’d move to Edinburgh to run the newspapers. Jack, successful in his own right, declined.
Things were going well in Canada. His team was steadily buying newspapers in Canada and Florida. They even acquired two television stations in partnership with a local senator. But it would be three years before Roy’s Edinburgh newspapers stopped losing money, which happened in 1955. Even with this significant turnaround complete, Roy was not content; he was back in grow-my-empire mode and considering how to start Scotland’s first independent television station.
Roy Thomson Part 3: A Bromance, from Beginning to End
November 1936 changed Roy Thomson’s business life. That’s the month when Jack Kent Cooke, a 24-year-old traveling salesman, asked for a job at Roy’s radio station CJKL. Roy was having problems with a newly acquired station, CJCS, in Stratford, Ontario, and hired Jack to turn the station around. Within six months, the station was profitable, and Roy decided to sell it for $10,000 for a profit of $6,000. Roy became fond of Jack and hired him to oversee sales in a newly created Toronto office.
Jack’s superior sales skills took that responsibility off Roy’s plate. He spent more time “figuring,” as he called it. In 1938, Roy convinced Jack to move to Timmins to manage all aspects of all five radio stations. Everything was going well until a fire in April 1939 burned down the building that housed station CKGB and the Press newspaper in Timmins. Roy was underinsured, but he bounced back. He borrowed to build a building for both his companies.
The world was on the cusp of World War II, and rumors circulated that paper would be rationed and sent to the United States. Roy figured this would lead to more advertising dollars flowing to radio, especially since more people were listening to their radios to receive war news. Not wanting to share the profits he envisioned his stations would produce in 1940, he bought back as much of his company stock as he could.
By 1940, the radio stations were running smoothly under Jack’s management. As Roy had predicted, the war was good for his radio business. Jack also found reinvestment opportunities for the profits that Northern Broadcasting and Publishing was generating. He and Roy partnered to buy their first French-language radio station in Quebec for $21,000. Two other purchases followed. Roy owned 66% of the partnership, and Jack owned 33%.
Roy and Jack expanded their radio empire by agreeing to manage Ontario radio stations owned by a senator. This capital-light approach gave the two partners 49% ownership in them.
The war, after it began, became a massive tailwind for Roy’s newspaper, too. Paper rationing made advertisers buy space in smaller rural papers, like the Press, because papers in big cities like Toronto were limited in pages and ad space.
The war had put Roy’s empire on solid financial ground for the first time. The depression years had conditioned Roy to keep salaries and expenses within budget, which boosted his profitability when wartime ad revenue surged. Roy standardized his accounting, making comparing the performance of his stations, apples to apples, easy.
Eager to reinvest profits, Roy upgraded his stations, paid off bank debt, and bought back outstanding stock in his company from outsiders. In 1943, Roy spent $880,000 to buy four newspapers with a $375,00 bank loan; the rest was seller financed. He owned eight radio stations and five newspapers after that deal closed. He and Jack agreed to a partnership in which they shared in each other’s deals; Roy got 66% and Jack 33%. The two started sourcing deals independently and evaluating and investing as a team.
Jack, eager to do more radio deals, found a Toronto radio station he could buy for $500,000. He didn’t have the money, so he convinced Roy to sell their Quebec stations. When those stations were sold, Jack's share of the proceeds provided him with capital he used to complete the purchase of the Toronto station. Roy declined to be part of the deal to buy the Toronto station, but within a few months, Jack had turned the station from unprofitable to solidly profitable. Jack became known as a radio station entrepreneur.
Roy bought two more newspapers in small towns for $750,000 and realized there was a big opportunity to purchase more small-town newspapers. Families had owned them for generations, had underinvested in them, and had to pay inheritance tax each time the ownership transferred to the next generation. Roy worked with investment bankers and issued $1,000,000 in bonds so he could go on a buying spree. Roy’s economic blueprint for buying and running rural newspapers would make him the millionaire he’d dreamed of being years earlier.
After Jack successfully managed the Ontario radio station for the senator, ran Roy’s stations, and turned around his Toronto station, a prominent media family approached him. They offered him a massive contract to manage their Ottawa radio station. On one condition: Roy could not be part of the deal. Jack accepted, and when he told Roy he wasn’t part of the deal, it was the end of their decade-plus friendship and partnership. Feeling betrayed and cut out by his young protegee, Roy started seeing Jack as a rival. The two divested themselves of ownership in each other’s companies and went their separate ways. Jack would later call that deal “one of the great mistakes in my life.”
With a thriving empire, Roy would soon begin to set his sights on taking his empire international.
Roy Thomson Part 2: The Making of a Media Mogul
According to the biography about him, Roy Thomson was determined to learn how to start a radio station. He tracked down the company that owned the license to broadcast in his area and struck a deal to acquire the license for $1. He struck another deal to set up his station in a building owned by a theatre company, paying in advertising time, not dollars. Station CFCH went live in March 1931.
Roy had solved his problem. Radio orders began rolling in. But he needed cash to pay for radios he’d gotten from the manufacturer on consignment. He landed a big contract with a large store in a rural community and leveraged that purchase order to borrow enough money to pay the manufacturer. Roy narrowly avoided bankruptcy.
Things remained tight for a few years, to the point that Roy’s employees knew they couldn’t immediately deposit their paychecks. Despite the shaky ground his business was on, Roy was elected North Bay alderman in 1931 and lost a bid to become mayor of North Bay in 1932. He then refocused his energies on expanding his business and eyed Timmins and Kirkland Lake, both in Ontario, as promising cities. Roy borrowed money from a bank and launched station CKGB in Timmins.
With CKGB flourishing, Roy partnered with a politically connected friend to get a radio license in Kirkland Lake. He raised money from wealthy Kirkland Lake residents and launched CJKL, which was well received. Roy was on a roll but still on thin ice financially.
When the local newspaper in Timmins, the Citizen, attacked Roy’s station CKGB for running ads for a competing newspaper, Roy offered to buy the unprofitable Citizen for $6,000. The owner, a gentleman named Bartleman, accepted, and Roy financed the deal by providing $200 at closing and giving Bartleman twenty-eight promissory notes for $200 each, payable over twenty-eight months. Roy sold his supply store to an employee. He changed the Citizen to the Timmins Press, and in 1934 Roy was a publisher.
To learn best practices for newspapers, Roy looked up the names of a hundred American cities the size of Timmins and ordered a copy of each one’s paper. He measured the layout of each paper and estimated the earning power of a small rural paper. Using his analysis, he optimized the size of each section of the Press to maximize its earning power.
Roy also realized that he had to publish more frequently to beat the competing town paper. He went from weekly to twice a week and, finally, daily in September 1935. Going daily was painful for his staff to execute. Readers got their papers late for a few months until his team got the hang of things. Roy ended up having to borrow $4,000 to upgrade his equipment to make daily publication feasible, but the investment paid off. Readers enjoyed having a daily paper, and the Press became the popular town newspaper.
Roy wasn’t able to pay the promissory notes, so he made Bartleman and his associate directors on his board and gave them ownership stakes in his company. With an eye on growth, Roy bought another station, CJCS, in Stratford, Ontario. The fact that he never had enough money in his accounts to cover payroll didn’t stop Roy from acquiring to grow.
By this time, Roy was managing four radio stations, a paper, and team members in various cities. He didn’t have a partner, so he worked sixteen or seventeen hours a day, negatively impacting his time with his family. He lost some of his connection with them. But Roy was 42, and in his mind he was twelve years behind on becoming a millionaire, so the sacrifice was worth it. Little did he know he was about to meet someone who would help him take his company to the next level and improve his personal life.
Roy Thomson Part 1: Failing Forward
A few weeks ago, I listened to an interview with Syed Balkhi, founder of WPBeginner and Awesome Motive. He recommended the trilogy of books on Roy Thomson, who founded what became the Thomson Reuters media empire and whose family is one of the wealthiest families in Canada. I wanted to learn more about Roy, so I read Roy Thomson of Fleet Street by Russell Braddon.
Roy was born in 1894 and raised in Toronto, Canada, by working-class parents. As a kid, he developed a love for numbers. For fun, he manually calculated the statistics of all baseball players from information he found in newspapers. At age 14, to help his family, he dropped out of school and started working full-time doing administrative work for local businesses.
Roy’s aunt was a shrewd investor. But Roy was shocked to learn she didn’t keep any records. He used his newly acquired bookkeeping skills to record her investments. She rewarded him by loaning him money to invest alongside her. Roy was obsessed with making money and was excited to invest with his aunt. At 17, he proclaimed to coworkers he’d be a millionaire by age 30.
The investments with his aunt did well, and Roy reinvested profits to buy his employer’s stock. He built an impressive $15,000 portfolio. Roy excelled at work. He became a branch manager and did outside sales for a local company. That role was pivotal because it taught him how to sell and, more importantly, helped him discover his passion for doing deals.
In 1917, Roy married Irma, and by the end of 1918, they had two children. Anxious to get rich, he took his $15,000, quit his job, and moved his family to remote Saskatchewan to become a farmer. The decision to purchase and farm 640 acres was a disastrous mistake. Roy lost much of his investment when he gave up farming within a year. He was 25, and he realized he couldn’t take losses like that if he wanted to become a millionaire by 30.
Automobile sales were exploding in 1920. Roy and his brother Carl pooled their money to start a company selling replacement parts to garages. To expand, they bought a machine shop, and by 1924 they’d grown the company to $700,000 in sales.
Roy was buying parts from manufacturers and selling them to garages. Expanding this business required inventory, which required capital, which Roy and Carl didn’t have. When the garages were slow to pay their bills, Roy and Bill had cash flow issues. They almost went bankrupt.
The brothers reworked their debts, and Roy left Toronto for Ottawa, which he saw as an untapped market for automotive parts. He and Carl set up a new Ottawa company, Service Supplies Limited. At the same time, in 1925, radios were new. Manufacturers were eager to sell them to businesses that sold to consumers. Trying to dig himself out of debt, Roy started selling radios too. By 1928, the new company was doing $80,000 a year in sales and the debts from their shuttered business had been paid off.
Roy wasn’t satisfied. He wanted to grow the company more. Hearing about Trimmis and Kirkland Lake, two rural cities thriving because of gold mines in Ontario, Roy moved his family to North Bay, Ontario, in 1928. Roy realized he had to help rural dealers. They didn’t know how to sell radios to consumers. Roy devised a door-to-door sales strategy that let consumers test radios for a week. If they liked them, he hoped they’d buy them. The strategy was innovative, but there was a significant problem that Roy and his dealers had overlooked: there was no radio signal in this remote area. There was nothing for people to listen to on the radio.
With the depression beginning to affect Roy’s dealers and payments from them to Roy slowing, Roy started to ponder how he could solve this problem. The more he thought about it, the more he realized there was only one way to solve it. He had to start a radio station.
Billy Wilkerson Book 2, Part 5: The Conclusion
I finished reading a second biography on William Richard “Billy” Wilkerson’s life. Unlike the first one, this one detailed his entire journey until his death in 1972. It also focused more on what led to his founding The Hollywood Reporter and his various entertainment and restaurant ventures.
I shared many of my concluding thoughts on Billy’s journey in an earlier post after reading the first biography. This post is about additional insights from the second biography.
How Did Billy’s Earlier Years Impact His Journey?
The death of his father led to Billy working in the film industry. Over roughly fifteen years, he worked in various roles at various companies in film production and distribution. He also managed his friend’s nickelodeon (i.e., theatre) and sold ads and wrote for a motion picture trade paper. These years of experience schooled Billy on the industry from various perspectives and led to key insights about himself and the industry. First, he was an entrepreneur and wanted to be his own boss. Next, the owners of movie studios amassed more of the industry’s profits than anyone else. Last, trade publications could wield immense power over an industry. These three key insights shaped his trajectory.
Billy’s first wife leaving him scarred him deeply. He was married five times. He wasn’t particularly close with wives two through four because he put his work ahead of them. Only after he had children with his fifth wife did he make spending time with his family a priority.
How Did Billy Become So Successful?
This book details Billy’s questionable actions and associations with criminal figures. It painted a picture of someone who didn’t mind using illegal means to accomplish a goal or obtain wealth. Partly this may be a sign of his time and place, but it’s clear that Billy’s comfort with doing things that weren’t aboveboard led to financial success and outsize influence. Billy was willing to do things and go places others weren’t to get what he wanted. This approach came with a cost. Billy went into hiding in Paris to avoid being killed by Bugsy Siegel, he owned several bulletproof cars, and his house was stocked with guns.
Billy was driven to succeed by hatred for movie studio bosses. Movie studio heads ran monopolies and operated similarly to robber barons. Billy felt wronged when they didn’t give his film a chance and held that grudge for decades. His desire to topple the studio bosses fueled his passion to make the Hollywood Reporter successful and dismantle what he viewed as an unfair studio system.
Billy was naturally gifted at understanding the psychology of the rich and famous. He repeatedly used this understanding to create content in the Reporter and numerous successful entertainment and dining venues that resonated with this group and made them want to be associated with Billy.
What Kind of Entrepreneur Was Billy?
Billy was a founder who enjoyed taking an idea from inception to an operating business, but he got bored easily and didn’t enjoy managing businesses. He ruled with an iron fist, which wasn’t uncommon for that period in history. This book highlighted Billy’s ability to weather massive misfortunes. Billy refused to be taken out of the game regardless of what life threw at him. He simply took the hit and kept going.
What Did I Learn from Billy’s Journey?
Billy’s journey is a cautionary tale. He had outsize success and impacted the movie industry, but the costs of operating unethically were high. His relationships, personal and professional, weren’t healthy. He was hated by many people whose lives he harmed. And the book never described a man who lived a happy life.
Billy had an outsize impact on Hollywood and Las Vegas. He was a complex man who lived a complicated life. Anyone interested in learning more about Billy or old Hollywood may enjoy this book.
Billy Wilkerson, Book 2, Part 4: Revenge and Rebirth as a Family Man
In 1938, William Richard “Billy” Wilkerson and Edith divorced. Once again, Billy wasn’t single long. According to the biography I’m reading, he met Estelle Jackson Brown in October 1939, and they were married by December 1939. Billy’s personal life was stable again, but his business empire was shaky. He’d sold Café Trocadero so he wouldn’t have to pay bribes anymore, and California cracked down on vices like gambling.
Billy wasn’t the only one with business problems. Joe Schenck began having trouble coming up with $100,000 in cash for Willie Bioff every month to avoid unions striking at his 20th Century Fox. In early 1939, he gave Bioff a $100,000 company check, knowing that if the gangster deposited it, that would be enough evidence for authorities to bring Bioff down. Schenck alerted authorities to the deposited check, which instigated an FBI investigation. Schenck had opened Pandora’s box.
With investigators’ scrutiny heightened, Schenck convinced Billy to revamp his new investment, Arrowhead Springs Hotel, three hours from Hollywood in San Bernardino. Billy agreed and turned the hotel into an exclusive getaway for the rich and famous. Unable to shake his old habit, he introduced gambling, which exploded in popularity. It was so popular that U.S. Marshals raided the hotel and shut it down.
In April 1941, Schenck was convicted of tax evasion and faced three years in prison. He agreed to testify against Bioff for a reduced sentence. In May 1941, Bioff was indicted for tax evasion and extortion, but he turned the tables. He entered federal witness protection and agreed to spill everything he knew to have all charges dropped. In 1942, Schenck began serving eighteen months but was released in four months after favors were called in. In December 1943, Johnny Rosselli was convicted of extortion and sentenced to ten years. The Hollywood Syndicate had collapsed, but Billy was never arrested. He narrowly escaped jail, but he couldn’t avoid another divorce. He and Brownie divorced in August 1942.
Around this time, Billy embarked on his Flamingo Hotel project and inadvertently ended up partnering with Bugsy Siegel, which I detailed in posts here, here, and here. In February 1946, Billie met 27-year-old Vivian Dubois at his Hollywood restaurant LaRue. In May they were married in Las Vegas. Billy started expressing his hatred for communism and displeasure that the U.S. didn’t stop Russia and Joseph Stalin from drawing an iron curtain around Eastern Europe. With the help of Howard Hughes, Billy obtained an FBI list of movie-industry people who supported communism. He then published editorials in the Reporter naming these people. Billy was a free speech advocate, but not when it came to communism. The Reporter’s sales increased, and other publications followed suit. Congress issued subpoenas, and studio heads were forced to testify. Billy created an anti-Communist movement. Many people on the Hollywood blacklist lost their jobs or were denied employment, even if they were innocent.
As this crusade was happening, movie studio bosses were grappling with competition from television and an antitrust lawsuit that reached the Supreme Court. In 1948, the Court ruled 7 to 1 that movie studios owning theatres constituted a monopoly. Studios tried to negotiate a compromise with the government, and Billy sensed that he could finally get revenge against the studios. He convinced recently paroled Rosselli, who was angry that studio bosses refused to help him after he got out of prison, to pressure government contacts Rosselli had paid off for years to reject any compromise from studios. The studios were forced to sell their theatres, their revenue declined, and they could no longer lock talent into long-term contracts. Actors and agents gained leverage by forcing studios to bid against each other for their services. After twenty years, Billy had finally exacted revenge on the studio bosses who rejected him and the studio system he hated.
In 1950, Billy and Vivian divorced, and in 1951, he met Beatrice Ruby Noble, known as Tichi. The 24-year-old was a housekeeper at Schenck’s beach house. Tichi became pregnant within a year, and after Billy realized she wasn’t trying to shake him down and medical tests confirmed he wasn’t sterile, the 60-year-old was excited to become a father. The two wed in 1951 and their son was born in October. Their daughter was born in 1953. Billy, now a family man, stopped gambling and started spending more time enjoying his wife and children.
Billy entertained the idea of selling the Reporter, but he decided to keep it. He continued running it in his mercurial style. Going to great lengths to end his partnership with Tom Seward after Seward sued him for paying gambling debts with partnership funds, Billy burned twenty years of business records. He ended up paying Seward $150,000 after much litigation, subpoenas, and search warrants, but he maintained complete control of his empire, which he ruled over until he died in 1962.
Billy was a complicated and flawed entrepreneur. Despite his shortcomings, he had a significant impact on Hollywood and entertainment in the United States. The Reporter is still in existence over ninety years after its founding.
Billy Wilkerson, Book 2, Part 3: The Dark Side
As prohibition ended, organized crime, needing new revenue streams, began looking at the movie industry. Mobster Johnny Rosselli approached William Richard “Billy” Wilkerson about taking over Hollywood labor unions. According to the biography I’m reading, Billy brought in Joseph Schenck, head of 20th Century Fox, and the trio formed the Hollywood Syndicate. The group helped gangster George Browne get elected as the president of the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees (IATSE), and Browne appointed Willie Bioff, also a gangster, as “his personal representative.” If IATSE called a strike, no movies could be produced. The Hollywood Syndicate started extracting a roughly $ 50,000-a-year bribe from each studio.
Around this time, Edith and Billy divorced. Edith was frustrated by their inability to have children and blamed Billy for not paying his 1929 debt to the New York City loan shark when her sister disappeared. Even though they divorced in August 1935, Edith continued working at The Hollywood Reporter until she retired in 1948. Billy was about 45, and he didn’t stay single long. In September, he met 20-year-old Rita Anne “Billie” Seward and married her by the end of that month. Billie’s brother, Tom Seward, became Billy’s right-hand man.
Gossip was a big part of what the Reporter published, and it sometimes led to scandals. This rubbed the studios the wrong way, and they would pull advertising from the publication. Billy’s response wasn’t always aboveboard. Sometimes he’d sell the same charity ad to several sponsors. Billy’s trick was to name only the charity in the ad, not the sponsor, so he could sell the ad up to a dozen times. This and other questionable tactics helped Billy fight back against the studios, and by 1936, the Reporter was known as “Hollywood’s Bible” and was capable of launching or killing careers. The studios had to respect the power Billy wielded.
As Billy’s success continued, he wanted to expand. He viewed London as a rapidly growing film market and launched the London Reporter in 1936. But British advertisers were part of an old-boy network, and Billy wasn’t invited in. The publication failed within five months. Billy next expanded his building and decided to try a new concept in the unused space. He started a high-end barbershop and men’s clothing store called Sunset House. It failed, and Billy lost $250,000.
By 1937, Billy’s marriage was falling apart. Billie wanted to adopt children, but the sterile Billy refused. In 1938, they divorced. That wasn’t the only thing falling apart. The Hollywood Syndicate was having problems with Bioff. Drunk on power, be began shaking down people the Syndicate hadn’t approved. Then he took things to the extreme and started to shake down Billy, demanding 50% of his restaurant profits or he’d have the workers strike at Café Trocadero. He demanded a $100,000 monthly payment from Schenck to avoid a strike at his 20th Century Fox studios. Both men agree to pay, with Billy paying roughly $20,000 a month. That same year, Billy decided he wanted out of the restaurant business and hired gangster Nola Hahn to stage a kitchen fire at Café Trocadero. Billy collected the insurance money and sold the property to Hahn for $268,000.
Billy’s problems were far from over. The secretive Hollywood Syndicate wouldn’t remain a secret for much longer.
Billy Wilkerson, Book 2, Part 2: The Midas Touch
William Richard “Billy” Wilkerson arrived in California in 1930 and set up Daily Printers Corporation in July. According to the biography, he borrowed $5,000 and launched The Hollywood Reporter. Printing costs were so high at the time that he bought a printing company so he could print in-house. His wife, Edith, handled administration and customer accounts and wrote much of the editorial copy.
Billy focused on writing a front-page editorial column called “Tradeviews.” It was part gossip and part Billy’s opinions. This column made him famous and would be a valuable weapon. Billy used it to criticize the Hollywood studio system, and the studio heads didn’t appreciate it. They tried to strong-arm Billy into writing what they wanted, but he refused. The studios retaliated and refused to advertise with him until he did as they said.
Billy was focused on providing content that readers wanted, which would grow his reader base. He instructed his reporters to do whatever had to be done to gather information—even go through the studios’ garbage. And Billy knew the studios didn’t treat workers well, so he championed the causes of blue-collar studio workers, directors, and others, which built him a loyal fan base. When newspapers around the country started picking up the Reporter’s editorials, Billy had the power to stop people from going to the movies, which reduced studio revenue.
By 1931, the Reporter was flush with ads and had power over the studios, who realized their plan to crush Billy had backfired. When Billy proved to Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM) head Louis B. Mayer that 5,000 papers nationwide reprinted the Reporter’s articles, Mayer was dumbfounded. Mayer and other studio heads agreed to yearly ad contracts with the Reporter to keep the peace with Billy. In just two years, Billy made the Reporter the most important film industry publication in Hollywood and was getting revenge on the people who killed his dream of owning a studio.
Billy and Edith missed New York food, and Billy was tired of driving around town for meetings. In May 1933, Billy opened Vendome, a lunchtime restaurant in Hollywood. He stocked delicacies from Europe and even sold European booze under the counter. This, combined with daily ads in the Reporter, made the restaurant the place to be seen by celebrities and the wealthy. It was wildly successful.
In 1933, President Roosevelt’s five-day bank holiday closed banks nationwide to prevent bank runs. Studios took advantage of this, and MGM forced employees to take a 50% pay cut for eight weeks or be fired. Billy learned about MGM’s plan to make the reductions permanent and wrote a blistering piece in the Reporter backing the writers’ union. Furious, Mayer reversed the pay reduction at MGM. He was so worried about Billy’s power and influence through the Reporter that he tried to buy Billy’s business for $300,000. Billy refused to sell.
Billy didn’t just fight the studios; he also had to fight competition. New York City–based Variety was a successful weekly trade publication that began covering Hollywood in 1933 when it launched Daily Variety. Realizing he could be put out of business by the larger competitor, Billy began a war to stop Variety from getting advertising sales. He even set up a dirty-tricks department to wage this war. The tactics worked and Billy fended off the competitor, albeit with questionable tactics.
In 1934, Billy faced a challenge when his insurance required that the abandoned building he was renting for wine storage not remain vacant. Unable to rent it out or find another use, he decided to open Café Trocadero, a French-themed restaurant and nightclub. To get people to come to the empty establishment, he claimed reservations were booked two weeks out and put velvet ropes outside to make people wait. In 24 months, it had grossed $3.8 million, making it the most successful Depression-era restaurant and nightclub in America. Billy had the Midas touch.
In a few short years, Billy had gone from broke to the upper echelons of entertainment and business by fighting against the studio heads. Billy was about to take his hatred of the studios to another level—one that was illegal.